A Board Crisis - D&O Insurance

You can blame the Boom ‘90’s for the past three (3) years of diving stock prices, but it has been accounting misdeeds and corporate wrong doing that has caught the media’s attention and has been the primary driver behind the current Directors and Officers Liability crisis.  Yes, the pre-2000 soft insurance market is also a factor, but each reported scandal has exposed Insurers to hundreds of millions of dollars in potential claims.

If you are a large and visible public corporation, you have probably seen your D&O Insurance premium double.  Even smaller but financially distressed companies, or companies that find themselves in the headlines or organizations in healthcare, telecommunications, or technology, have seen their D&O Insurance premiums increase substantially in 2002.  One hundred (100%) percent increases were not unusual.  For private companies not in those industry’s, the news is not quite as bad, but rates are still up 30-35%.  Could it happen again in 2003?  Oh yes!

It used to be that ‘Excess’ layers were available at discounted rates over primary (first dollar) policies.  That is not always the case anymore.  Quite often, Excess layers are the same cost as the primary.

Coverage provisions are also changing.  Many insurers want insureds to accept coinsurance provisions rather than just deductibles.  Some Insurers are requesting 25-30% coinsurance sharing provisions so their insureds interest in settling cases matches their own.

As a result of the media’s attention to high profile corporate misconduct and accounting irregularities, a cry arose for “corporate governance”.  Out of that, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act came about.  The intent was to reform corporate accounting practices.  The jury is still out on the impact on Corporate America.  The truth be told, ‘most’ CEO’s and CFO’s felt responsible before Sarbanes-Oxley.

Insurers and stockholders alike have come to an unfortunate conclusion.  They can no longer simply accept audit reports.  They now need to spend extra time to thoroughly evaluate and verify corporate finances.  We find Insurers are now asking for a lot more detailed information and are taking longer to evaluate potential insureds.  It is putting everyone through a lot more work and aggravation.

Bottom-line, D&O Liability Insurance is at a crisis point.  There still are willing insurers, but you will probably pay more for less next renewal.

Article contributed by Chuck Rosenberger of NuWest Insurance Services.  He can be reached at 949-752-8744.